Old Bermuda Inn | Staten Island

The Historic Old Bermuda Inn – Detailed Overview

Location

Address: 301 Veterans Road West, Staten Island, NY 10309

Conveniently located near the West Shore Expressway, offering easy access from Staten Island, Brooklyn, and New Jersey.

History

Built in 1832 by the Mersereau family as a summer home.

Later became the parsonage for St. Luke’s Church in the 1840s.

The structure reflects 19th-century architecture and has been carefully preserved and restored over time.

Now serves as a historic landmark and popular venue for events.

Architecture and Setting

The building exhibits classic Victorian and Colonial Revival architectural styles.

Surrounded by gardens, terraces, and wooded areas, the Inn maintains a charming and elegant historic ambiance.

The property features multiple event spaces with different atmospheres, from intimate rooms to grand halls.

Facilities

The Inn includes six distinct event rooms and halls, each with unique décor and capacity:

Castle Harbour — a grand space for larger events.

Harmony Hall & Grotto Bay — ideal for mid-sized gatherings.

The Mansion & Trimingham Room — historic rooms with elegant touches.

Parakeet Room — cozy and intimate.

Hamilton Square & Swizzle Inn — perfect for cocktail parties or smaller receptions.

Chapel — used for ceremonies and special occasions.

Bed & Breakfast accommodations:

Four individually decorated suites featuring antiques blended with modern comforts.

Common areas include a Grand Parlor with a fireplace and piano.

Events and Services

Renowned for hosting weddings, receptions, anniversaries, Sweet 16s, bridal/baby showers, corporate events, and private parties.

Offers customized event planning with tailored menus, decor, and entertainment options.

Awarded recognition as Staten Island’s best caterer for their exceptional food and service.

Special events include Victorian tea parties and cocktail hours featuring gourmet stations.

Experienced event coordinators assist clients from start to finish.

Cuisine

Menus focus on gourmet cuisine using fresh, high-quality ingredients.

Options include plated dinners, buffet-style service, cocktail hors d’oeuvres, and specialty food stations.

Custom menus can accommodate dietary restrictions and cultural preferences.

Haunted History and Legends

The Inn is reputedly haunted by Martha Mersereau, the original mistress.

Martha’s husband died in the Civil War, and she reportedly kept a candle burning in her window awaiting his return.

Staff and visitors have reported:

Sightings of Martha’s ghost, especially in the dining room (her former bedroom).

Sounds of footsteps, voices, and doors opening or closing on their own.

Strange cold spots and unexplained occurrences.

These stories add a layer of mystique and intrigue to the historic property.

Why It’s Special

The Inn offers a unique combination of historic charm, elegant atmosphere, and modern amenities.

Its long history and well-preserved architecture provide a memorable setting for events.

The haunted lore adds character and a captivating story that fascinates guests.

Its location on Staten Island’s West Shore makes it accessible while maintaining a peaceful, picturesque environment.

This combination of history, hospitality, and haunting mystery makes the Historic Old Bermuda Inn a beloved Staten Island landmark and a premier venue for special occasions.